When we were last met to discuss Maggie Ross's wonderfully cool diagnosis of much that ails us, Silence: A User's Guide, I sketched out some of the background influences and concerns to this book, and to my reading of it. I also noted one or two places in the first part of the book where we get some hints of what is to come as we move now into the third chapter, "The Language of Silence," where Ross really lets fly, inveighing against many common, but even more commonly misunderstood and misapplied terms, concepts, and practices.
This entire third chapter, as I commented previously, really could bear the title "Glossary of Nonsense Terms Fatuously Flung About by Careless Christians." In the book it functions very much as an excursus between the background she lays out in chs.1-2, and the objections to silence in the rest of the book. I will only give you a taste, but the entire chapter is very much worth your time.
One of the biggest misunderstandings--as I have long thought myself--comes down to the primacy people give to the notion of "experience," which Ross says is "perhaps the most significant of the frequently misused words in this list." Experience, Ross says, is solipsistic in today's usage, running totally contrary to "ancient, patristic, and medieval" wariness of the term; it invites narcissism and notions of control.
Faith is another misused word--and here Ross agrees very much with Fr. Paul Tarazi, as his interview on here last week showed--because it refers, wrongly, to a set of abstract doctrines rather than the practice of trust.
Mystical/Mystic/Mysticism: All these terms "have become useless and misleading" and function to justify "weirdness," "exoticism," "voyeurism (a kind of spiritual pornography" (90). See below for more on the problems with "mysticism."
Spiritual Direction: I was moving from studying psychology to theology in the late 1990s when all of a sudden it seemed (as I noted in part I) that the study of something called "spirituality" exploded in revolting fashion, and along with it, very predictably, came the attempts to make money off that by people setting themselves up as "spiritual directors" everywhere, offering expensive courses in how you, too, could become a director, or at least benefit from on-going direction. A couple of these people to whom I spoke, including one woman in charge of just such a brand-new centre for spiritual direction and formation, were so dim and tedious, so incurious and uninformed about everything, that I felt myself falling rapidly into a coma after about two sentences.
But what these newly minted "spiritual directors" lacked in intellectual substance was more than made up for by the aggressively preening self-importance of their tone. All this is to say I greatly cheered Ross's denunciation of "spiritual direction,
so-called" as having "little to no relationship to the desert practice of
manifestation of thoughts. It evolved as a form of mind control." As she continues, "modern so-called spiritual direction is counter-productive and a distraction: it tends to make the 'directee' become increasingly preoccupied with his or her self-construct and imagined 'spiritual life' instead of moving towards self-forgetfulness in beholding the divine other."
After this swamp-clearing excursus, the rest of the book is a more extended critical analysis of how to practice silence and of the obstacles towards doing so. She begins chapter 4 by briefly surveying how few modern thinkers are interested in silence because they operate under a Cartesian method. Of the few who, she says, escape this influence to some extent, she cites the Canadians Charles Taylor and Bernard Lonergan; and the Greek Orthodox scholar John Panteleimon Manoussakis, whom I interviewed here.
One of the points Ross makes clear here, and elsewhere in the book, is that most of us have lost the capacity for observing how our minds work. Indeed, as Christopher Bollas (inter alia) has also recently noted, we live in a time that scorns the idea of thinking about our minds and the unconscious influences on them. But this loss, this refusal, this scorn, makes us incapable of enduring silence and so living in the wellsprings of the deep mind. Without this, we are bereft of what we need for any serious transfiguration in our life. (In this regard I would say that Ross's critique echoes those who suggest our reliance on overly hasty "cures" approved by modern "therapists" and pharmaceutical companies, and especially the insurance companies who pay the bills of both, are, as I suggested here, far less effective than the slower work of often silently lying on the couch of unknowing.)
It is that lack of control over "unknowing" that makes silence so suspect. Much of this and later chapters in her book are spent by Ross discussing problems with the many translations of the famous work The Cloud of Unknowing, almost all versions of which use the word "experience and other anachronisms" the effect of which is to "have obscured behold, so that it rarely appears." Beholding something, as she is at pains to show at length, is different from thinking we "experience" (and thus presumably, at least partially, control) it. It is the Gallacher edition of the Cloud (linked above and at left) that she says almost alone avoids this problem.
Later on she also decries the elimination of "behold" and cognates from modern biblical translations. This term, she says, is "arguably the most important word in the Bible..., which occurs more than 1300 times in the Hebrew and Greek" (179).
Lots of churchmen, she says, have been quite content to eliminate ideas of beholding and the silence which it requires, in part because both are suspect and hard to control. Of those very few not guilty of this, Ross cites some of the Desert Fathers and Mothers, including our old friend Evagrius, whom I have often cited on here and whom I taught to my students last semester. According to Ross, the writings of Evagrius "speak to human beings in every age....His advice is just as applicable today in an urban culture."
In the final part of the book Ross presents something of an apologia for the fruits of silence, noting that there is a reciprocal relationship: the more one enters into the silence of the deep mind, the more mind is released from tightly held ideas and hostile emotions, especially avarice, anger, and judgment. Instead of these, one emerges more compassionate, detached, and willing to forgive. At the same time, she notes, one's powers of discernment are heightened as silence encourages a ruthless honesty.
For those worried about the "political" implications of all this, Ross is clear in several places that emergence into silence does not give rise to a crabbed "me and my cell and the rest of you go to hell" Christianity. Rather, she says the ethics and politics of silence are "green" in caring for creation. Silence, she says, makes one simultaneously more liberal and more conservative: liberal in wanting to share the riches with everyone, and conservative in wanting to hang onto the experience of silence and protect it via a sort of "custody of the ears." Those who are immersed in silence come quickly to have a pronounced intolerance for reading about violence, for going to loud parties and pointless meetings, etc.
Finally, those who live in silence find there a refuge but not an escape. The silent are never at home in our culture again, but are able nonetheless to live because the richness of silence enables a life-sustaining transfiguration, which this book, Silence: A User's Guide, itself goes some very considerable distance to advancing in surprising and welcome ways.
Concluded.
"Let books be your dining table, / And you shall be full of delights. / Let them be your
mattress,/And you shall sleep restful nights" (St. Ephraim the Syrian).
mattress,/And you shall sleep restful nights" (St. Ephraim the Syrian).
Showing posts with label Desert Fathers/Mothers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Desert Fathers/Mothers. Show all posts
Monday, February 26, 2018
On Fasting from Noise or Against Asceticism and Spirituality (II)
Monday, August 1, 2016
Desert Mothers, Daughters, and Granddaughters
I have often noted on here collections devoted to the Desert Fathers and Mothers. In October of this year we will have another scholarly collection devoted to a desert mother and her daughter: Catherine M. Chin and Caroline T. Schroeder, eds., Melania: Early Christianity through the Life of One Family (U California Press, 2016), 314pp.
About this book we are told:
About this book we are told:
Melania the Elder and her granddaughter Melania the Younger were major figures in early Christian history, using their wealth, status, and forceful personalities to shape the development of nearly every aspect of the religion we now know as Christianity. This volume examines the influence that these two women had on the development of Christianity and provides an insightful portrait of the their legacies in the modern world. Instead of the traditionally patriarchal view, this perspective gives a poignant and sometimes surprising view of how the rise of Christian institutions in the Roman Empire shaped the understanding of women's roles in the larger world.
Monday, October 26, 2015
The Wisdom of the Desert in our Time
I was delighted recently to receive in the mail from St. Vladimir Seminary Press a new book that I said more than ten years ago needed to be written. In the early part of the last decade I was taking a graduate class on the Desert Fathers/Mothers, and trying to see connections between the "psychology" of such monastics as Evagrius and the world of the twenty-first century, especially in the aftermath of Freud. I was greatly attracted to the vision of "interiorized monasticism" that Paul Evdokimov touched upon in his lovely and lyrical (but not unproblematical) book The Sacrament of Love, but found that vision underdeveloped and not adequately "translated" and thus made accessible to non-scholars today.
Now, however, we happily have a very useful and edifying attempt to link the wisdom of desert monasticism to the world of our own day in a way that does not require all of us to flee to real deserts or try to climb atop a stylus somewhere. That book is A Layman in the Desert: Monastic Wisdom for a Life in the World (SVS Press, 2015; 201pp.) by Daniel Opperwall, whom I asked for an interview. Here are his thoughts.

AD: Tell us about your background
Now, however, we happily have a very useful and edifying attempt to link the wisdom of desert monasticism to the world of our own day in a way that does not require all of us to flee to real deserts or try to climb atop a stylus somewhere. That book is A Layman in the Desert: Monastic Wisdom for a Life in the World (SVS Press, 2015; 201pp.) by Daniel Opperwall, whom I asked for an interview. Here are his thoughts.

AD: Tell us about your background
DO: I was born and raised in suburban Detroit. I was
baptized Presbyterian as a baby, but my family stopped going to church at all
when I was about six. I got a really excellent education that left me
interested in philosophy and literature. As most teenagers interested in that
kind of thing, I decided to be an atheist for a time. In my early twenties,
though, as I kept on reading, atheism became more and more absurd to me, and
Jesus Christ became more and more compelling. But a lot of the Christianity I
knew still seemed off. Then I encountered Orthodoxy, and everything connected.
So, I converted.
AD: What led to the writing of this book, A Layman in the Desert: Monastic Wisdom for a Life in the World, in particular?
DO: There is a big trend in the Orthodox Church of people
getting interested in patristic literature and monastic spirituality. But people
often struggle when they are reading this stuff--they worry that maybe it's
impossible to seek salvation without becoming a monk or a nun. It seemed to me
that the problem comes when we fail to assess the core teachings being shared
in this kind of literature so as to appropriately translate them into our real
lives. How do I seek detachment while owning a car? How do I seek chastity if I
am married and thus have sex? We cannot just try to do what ancient monks did--our
lives don't permit that. So, we have to seek the same holiness as they did, but
through our own lives as we really live them (not, that is, in spite of those lives). I
decided to look at John Cassian's Conferences to see how that might be
possible. Layman is what came out.
AD: Some might be puzzled by the
seeming paradox in your sub-title: monastic
wisdom for a life in the world. Don’t
we all assume that monks are supposed to be world-fleeing and world-denying?
Well, for one thing, the notion that there is a great
chasm between monastics and the rest of the world is far less true than we
sometimes imagine, and it was, if anything, even less true in the ancient
world. The ancient monks, even hermits, were constantly receiving news and
visits--they were very engaged. So, one thing that became important in Layman
was simply bringing forward what St John already says about worldly
life--he knew a lot about it.
But still, there is a difference here. The ancient hermits were trying to get away from the world as much as they could. Yet, they came to tremendous wisdom about God and human beings--wisdom that applies to everyone no matter what their situation. Layman is precisely about getting at that insight--that wisdom--and developing a theory of how to bring it back into our lives in the world. I hope that task seems a bit less paradoxical in light of the book, and I hope this is far from the last word we see on it.
But still, there is a difference here. The ancient hermits were trying to get away from the world as much as they could. Yet, they came to tremendous wisdom about God and human beings--wisdom that applies to everyone no matter what their situation. Layman is precisely about getting at that insight--that wisdom--and developing a theory of how to bring it back into our lives in the world. I hope that task seems a bit less paradoxical in light of the book, and I hope this is far from the last word we see on it.
AD: Your Athonite interlocutor,
quoted in your preface, notes that a “monastery” is simply a place where people
help one another unto salvation—just as a family does together. But why do you
think that many people either fail to realize that, or otherwise assume that a
family is a “lesser” calling?
I think it is a natural mistake to see monastics as
special. There are far fewer of them then us, and nobody is born a monk or nun.
We also tend to mistakenly equate Church-related things for the work of being
Christian. So, since monastics spend far more time in church, we think of them
as somehow more Christian. If we are only Christian in church, though, then
there is no hope for anyone. And, honestly, the Church could do a much better
job of disavowing people of these ideas. We have far too little material on
married saints, for example--and what we have often involves couples living in
celibacy so that they are basically just monastics again! The priest I met on
Mt Athos knew far too much about real monastic life to fall into these traps,
but for us lay people monks and nuns often remain mystical super-humans. We
have to stop thinking like that.
AD: You note that Orthodox today do
not want for practical books on fasting, praying the Jesus prayer at work,
moral isues, or generally leading a life in the world; but that of those many
books, few focus on what the “essential spiritual character and purpose” of a
lay life is. Tell us how you understand that character and purpose.
The driving realization of Layman is that we,
as lay people, have to be seeking our salvation through our lives in the
world, not just in those moments of prayer or going to church. We have to be
growing closer to Christ when mowing the lawn, cooking dinner, going to work,
going to the bank. If we can't find ways to do that, then there really is no
hope for us. Our purpose is nothing short of theosis in Christ--that is
God's purpose for all people. But we are being asked to seek that in the world most
of the time rather than through obviously religious things--that is the
challenging character of our spirituality.
AD: You also note that we do not want
for books, especially recent translations, of wisdom from desert fathers and
mothers, but we do want for books translating that wisdom into an idiom for our
own day. Why have we waited so long for a book such as yours? What has
prevented others from undertaking such efforts as yours?
When it comes to the English-speaking Church, I think
our writers and scholars have just had other priorities so far. I don't blame
them for that. It was not long ago that we had virtually no books in English
about Orthodox theology, church history, liturgics. We got some of those, so
then we started working on translations of our classic writings, and that work
has borne fruit only in the last few years. Now that we have our feet on the
ground with those more essential things, we can start getting into the nuanced
conversations about the shape of Orthodox life in the modern West.
AD: As you combed through the vast
literature on desert wisdom, you came to focus in particular on John Cassian: The Conferences. Tell us,
first, how you came to focus on him rather than other desert fathers and
mothers.
The Conferences maintain a beautiful balance
between accessibility and depth. A collection like the The Sayings of the Desert Fathers, for instance, would be hard to write about since it is all short
snippets without many sustained themes or discussions. Conversely, the Philokalia
is utterly vast, and often almost esoteric. The Conferences falls
right in between so that there is enough to dig into for a book like this, but
it remains approachable for those without lots of theological training. It also
appealed to me because it bridges the East/West divide that we too often set up
in thinking about Orthodox history. The Conferences is part of the full
Orthodox heritage--east and west.
St John is something of a mystery in a lot of ways. We
can say just a few things with certainty. He spent a lot of time in several
monasteries in Egypt, and travelled among the desert hermits there (whose
teachings he records in the Conferences). At some point he went to Gaul
(modern France) to set up several monasteries near Marseilles. That is around
the time that he wrote the Conferences. We are not sure if he grew up
speaking Latin or Greek, but he seems to have known both very well by the time
he started writing (the Conferences are originally in Latin). St John
can be a very beautiful, and remarkably honest writer. In the Conferences,
he records accounts of what several desert hermits said to him and his friend
Germanus as they went through the desert. He often records the questions that
Germanus asks, and many of them can be challenging, critical, flippant, even
slightly annoyed and funny. Sometimes St John will even express uncertainty
about a teaching or situation--he does not try to make everything seem
clear-cut. Because of all that, when reading the Conferences one really
gets the feeling of sitting at the feet of the elders, talking back and forth
with them. They feel like human beings, not impossible spiritual super-heroes.
It's a beautiful way of recording all this ancient wisdom, and that is a big
part of why the Conferences became some of the most influential texts in
the development of Christian monasticism.
AD: Sum up what your hopes or goals
for A Layman in the Desert: Monastic Wisdom for a Life in the World are, and who in particular should read it.
My main hope is to start a conversation that lets us
put lay spirituality into better focus. I'm not trying to transform the
spiritual lives of lay people, or give them a different role in the Church, or
anything like that; I want us to better understand the role that we lay people
already play--the spiritual lives we are already living--and therefore try to
strengthen them. So, to that end, I think basically any serious Orthodox lay
person, and probably a good number of Catholics, would benefit from giving it a
read. Other Christians might get a lot of food for thought as well, though the
monastic tradition might seem a little more unusual to many Protestants and
others.
AD: Having finished A Layman in the Desert: Monastic Wisdom for a Life in the World, what
are you at work on now? Other books in the works, or other research?
At the moment I have been thinking a lot about the
Council of Chalcedon, in fact. I've just finished presenting at a conference on
healing the Chalcedonian schism, and I will be teaching a course on the subject
as well in January. So, that's a change of pace--back into heavy historical
theology.
I haven't settled on a next book, but I am thinking very seriously about writing one on the Rule of St Benedict that would be in a similar vein to A Layman in the Desert. I'd like to explore how the Rule can be conceptually translated to help inform life in a family home rather than a monastery. My spiritual father is a Benedictine monk (yes there are Orthodox Benedictine monks!), and St Benedict drew a lot from St John Cassian, so it would be a natural next step.
I haven't settled on a next book, but I am thinking very seriously about writing one on the Rule of St Benedict that would be in a similar vein to A Layman in the Desert. I'd like to explore how the Rule can be conceptually translated to help inform life in a family home rather than a monastery. My spiritual father is a Benedictine monk (yes there are Orthodox Benedictine monks!), and St Benedict drew a lot from St John Cassian, so it would be a natural next step.
Monday, October 12, 2015
Laymen in Today's Plentiful Deserts
The invaluable St. Vladimir's Seminary Press recently sent me two books, including a book I wish I had had more than a decade ago in grad school when reading the desert fathers and mothers, and lamenting that so many of their riches had remained hidden in the tradition and not brought out to help Eastern Christians of the 21st century. Now such a book appears to have been written: Daniel Opperwall, A Layman in the Desert: Monastic Wisdom for a Life in the World (SVS Press, 2015), 201pp.
About this book we are told:
Orthodox Christians today have no lack of resources on monastic spirituality. And yet startlingly little has been done to critically engage the monastic tradition and adapt its ancient wisdom for the Orthodox faithful living in today s complex society. A Layman in the Desert aims to bridge this crucial gap.
Working with the Conferences of St John Cassian, Opperwall constructs a kind of relationship handbook that shows us how the desert saints of old can help us build healthy, Christ-centered relationships with our spouses, children, friends, and coworkers.
Wednesday, September 10, 2014
In Honour of Benedicta Ward, Mother of the Deserts of Today and Yesterday
You cannot have read in patristic literature in English today, especially monastic literature of the desert, without having come across the seemingly indefatigable translation work of Benedicta Ward. Author or editor of such collections as The Sayings of the Desert Fathers: The Alphabetical Collection and
The Desert Fathers: Sayings of the Early Christian Monks, she also authored the strikingly titled Harlots of the Desert: A Study of Repentance in Early Monastic Sources, all of which treat prominent figures in the Christian East. Moreover, she has cooperated with such prominent Orthodox scholars as Kallistos Ware and John Chryssavgis on books such as In the Heart of the Desert: The Spirituality of the Desert Fathers and Mothers;
with the late Russian Orthodox Archbishop Anthony Bloom on The Wisdom of the Desert Fathers; and with the brilliant translator of theological Greek, Norman Russell, on The Lives of the Desert Fathers: Historia Monachorum in Aegypto. She is, in sum, by any reckoning one of the leading scholars, editors, and translators of our time on this vast corpus of desert literature.
But Ward is a genuinely "catholic" scholar who also turned her attention to prominent medieval Western figures and periods, including a study of Bede and the Psalter as well as a monograph on The Synod of Whitby 664 AD, which synod I've seen tendentiously and anachronistically used and abused by both Anglican and Orthodox apologists in their fantastic myth-making about a supposedly (take your pick) pure "Anglican" or pure "Orthodox" practice of faith among the Angles and Celts before those big bad (take your pick) Franks/Romans/Latins came along and hijacked it after Whitby, leading to darkness and damnation that culminated, of course, in the grossly, almost violently misunderstood Anselm of Canterbury - His Life and Legacy, whom Orthodox apologists invariably, tediously, tiresomely caricature in the most lurid, fact-free ways. Ward has, doubtless, forgotten more about Anselm in this book and in her other study, Anslem of Canterbury Monastic Scholar, than any Orthodox blogger has ever bestirred him/herself to read, let alone understand (I read Anselm in the Latin original more than 20 years ago, and wouldn't dare claim to be an expert on him).
All this is just an introduction (which by no means exhausts her lengthy lists of publications) to a new Festschrift published for her. Such publications, alas, are often not best-sellers, and so publishers feel the need to recoup costs with large sticker prices, but that detracts nothing from the larger "worth" of this collection: Santha Bhattacharji and Dominic Mattos, eds., Prayer and Thought in Monastic Tradition: Essays in Honour of Benedicta Ward (Bloomsbury, 2014), 368pp.
About this book we are told:
The Desert Fathers: Sayings of the Early Christian Monks, she also authored the strikingly titled Harlots of the Desert: A Study of Repentance in Early Monastic Sources, all of which treat prominent figures in the Christian East. Moreover, she has cooperated with such prominent Orthodox scholars as Kallistos Ware and John Chryssavgis on books such as In the Heart of the Desert: The Spirituality of the Desert Fathers and Mothers;
with the late Russian Orthodox Archbishop Anthony Bloom on The Wisdom of the Desert Fathers; and with the brilliant translator of theological Greek, Norman Russell, on The Lives of the Desert Fathers: Historia Monachorum in Aegypto. She is, in sum, by any reckoning one of the leading scholars, editors, and translators of our time on this vast corpus of desert literature.
But Ward is a genuinely "catholic" scholar who also turned her attention to prominent medieval Western figures and periods, including a study of Bede and the Psalter as well as a monograph on The Synod of Whitby 664 AD, which synod I've seen tendentiously and anachronistically used and abused by both Anglican and Orthodox apologists in their fantastic myth-making about a supposedly (take your pick) pure "Anglican" or pure "Orthodox" practice of faith among the Angles and Celts before those big bad (take your pick) Franks/Romans/Latins came along and hijacked it after Whitby, leading to darkness and damnation that culminated, of course, in the grossly, almost violently misunderstood Anselm of Canterbury - His Life and Legacy, whom Orthodox apologists invariably, tediously, tiresomely caricature in the most lurid, fact-free ways. Ward has, doubtless, forgotten more about Anselm in this book and in her other study, Anslem of Canterbury Monastic Scholar, than any Orthodox blogger has ever bestirred him/herself to read, let alone understand (I read Anselm in the Latin original more than 20 years ago, and wouldn't dare claim to be an expert on him).
All this is just an introduction (which by no means exhausts her lengthy lists of publications) to a new Festschrift published for her. Such publications, alas, are often not best-sellers, and so publishers feel the need to recoup costs with large sticker prices, but that detracts nothing from the larger "worth" of this collection: Santha Bhattacharji and Dominic Mattos, eds., Prayer and Thought in Monastic Tradition: Essays in Honour of Benedicta Ward (Bloomsbury, 2014), 368pp.
About this book we are told:
Prayer and Thought in Monastic Tradition presents a chronological picture of the development of monastic thought and prayer from the early English Church (Bede, Adomnan) through to the 17th Century and William Law's religious community at King's Cliffe. Essays interactwith different facets of monastic life, assessing the development and contribution of figures such as Boniface, the Venerable Bede, Anselm of Canterbury and Bernard of Clairvaux. The varying modes and outputs of the monastic life of prayer are considered, with focus on the use of different literary techniques in the creation of monastic documents, the interaction between monksand the laity, the creation of prayers and the purpose and structure of prayer in different contexts. The volume also discusses the nature of translation of classic monastic works, and the difficulties the translator faces. The highly distinguished contributors include; G.R. Evans, Sarah Foot, Henry Mayr-Harting, Brian McGuire, Henry Wansbrough and Rowan Williams.
Wednesday, November 13, 2013
Anonymous Sayings of the Desert Fathers
I have noted on here several times in the past the burgeoning interest in, and literature on, the Desert Fathers (and Mothers). Another recent book by a respected historian was recently published offering us further insights into this world that continues to influence Eastern Christian spirituality: John Wortley, trans., The Anonymous Sayings of the Desert Fathers: A Select Edition and Complete English Translation (Cambridge University Press, 2013), 658pp.
About this book we are told:
The Tales and Sayings of the Desert Fathers (Apophthegmata Patrum) are a key source of evidence for the practice and theory respectively of eremitic monasticism, a significant phenomenon within the early history of Christianity. The publication of this book finally ensures the availability of all three major collections which constitute the work, edited and translated into English. Richer in Tales than the 'Alphabetic' collection to which this is an appendix (both to be dated c.AD 500), the 'Anonymous' collection presented in this volume furnishes almost as much material for the study of the late antique world from which the monk sought to escape as it does for the monastic endeavour itself. More material continued to be added well into the seventh century and so the spread and gradual evolution of monasticism are illustrated here over a period of about two and a half centuries.
Labels:
Desert Fathers/Mothers,
John Wortley
Monday, November 4, 2013
The Culture of Asceticism
Given David Fagerberg's recent excellent book (which I recently finished and reviewed for Nova et Vetera) as well as a few others either recently published or soon to emerge, it seems that there has been a recent upsurge in interest in "asceticism," which rather raises all sorts of interesting questions. One very much hopes that this is not the Christian spiritual equivalent of the latest "fad diet" that will soon be dropped in pursuit of whatever trend next emerges promising "spiritual enlightenment."
When it comes to asceticism broadly understood, I regularly hear some very good questions from my students, the Catholics especially, who wonder why it is that, in today's world, eating a $10 piece of salmon on Friday is somehow "ascetical" or constitutes "fasting" while eating a $3 chicken breast does not. Over which does God scruple more--the money spent or the nature of the flesh consumed? How, in a state like Indiana far from the oceans, is spending a lot of money to eat shrimp or scallops or, better yet, lobster, in keeping with Great Lent whereas eating pork or chicken or even beef is not? The best answer to such questions, I think, was suggested by my friend the Orthodox priest and theologian Michael Plekon: the important thing is to eat simply so as to free up money to give to the poor and free up time to give to prayer. If grabbing a cheap burger allows both to happen, but preparing an elaborate tofu and quinona concoction does not, then perhaps one ought to go with the former. But doing so is an individual decision when fasting and abstinence are also communal or ecclesial practices and if there is a change then perhaps we should all change together.
Given periodic shifts in ascetical practices, discussed in a book just published this week, perhaps it is time to revisit these issues today--an item, as some Orthodox have suggested, for the agenda of the council in the works lo these many decades: Blake Leyerle and Robin Darling Young, eds., Ascetic Culture: Essays in Honor of Philip Rousseau (University of Notre Dame Press, 2013), 416pp.
About this book we are told:
When it comes to asceticism broadly understood, I regularly hear some very good questions from my students, the Catholics especially, who wonder why it is that, in today's world, eating a $10 piece of salmon on Friday is somehow "ascetical" or constitutes "fasting" while eating a $3 chicken breast does not. Over which does God scruple more--the money spent or the nature of the flesh consumed? How, in a state like Indiana far from the oceans, is spending a lot of money to eat shrimp or scallops or, better yet, lobster, in keeping with Great Lent whereas eating pork or chicken or even beef is not? The best answer to such questions, I think, was suggested by my friend the Orthodox priest and theologian Michael Plekon: the important thing is to eat simply so as to free up money to give to the poor and free up time to give to prayer. If grabbing a cheap burger allows both to happen, but preparing an elaborate tofu and quinona concoction does not, then perhaps one ought to go with the former. But doing so is an individual decision when fasting and abstinence are also communal or ecclesial practices and if there is a change then perhaps we should all change together.
Given periodic shifts in ascetical practices, discussed in a book just published this week, perhaps it is time to revisit these issues today--an item, as some Orthodox have suggested, for the agenda of the council in the works lo these many decades: Blake Leyerle and Robin Darling Young, eds., Ascetic Culture: Essays in Honor of Philip Rousseau (University of Notre Dame Press, 2013), 416pp.
About this book we are told:
Ascetic Culture honors Philip Rousseau’s pathbreaking work on early Christian asceticism in a series of essays exploring how quickly the industrious and imaginative practitioners of asceticism, from the early fourth through the mid-fifth century, adapted the Greco-Roman social, literary, and religious culture in which they had been raised. Far from rejecting the life of the urban centers of the ancient world, they refined and elaborated that life in their libraries, households, and communities.The volume begins with a discussion of Egyptian monastic reading programs and the circulation of texts, especially the hugely influential Life of Antony. A second group of essays engages the topic of disciplinary culture in ascetic spaces such as the monastery, the household, and the city. A third group focuses on the topic of imaginary landscapes and ascetic self-fashioning. Ascetic Culture concludes by surveying the scholarly study of asceticism over the last one hundred and fifty years, arguing that previous generations of scholars have regarded asceticism either as a product of the inner dynamism of early Christianity or as a distortion of its earliest aims. Together, the contributors recognize, reflect upon, and extend the themes explored in Rousseau’s work on early Christianity’s ascetic periphery—a region whose inhabitants reflect in various ways the aspirations of their religion, from the daily to the otherworldly.
Monday, July 1, 2013
The Desert and the Copts Today
The Coptic scholar Lois Farag recently published one book, and late this year will publish another one. The first is Balance of the Heart: Desert Spirituality for Twenty-First-Century Christians (Wipf and Stock, 2012), 282pp.
About this book we are told:
The publisher provides the following details about this forthcoming book:
About this book we are told:
Desert spirituality speaks to the mind and heart. It is a spirituality that helps us balance our work and daily obligations and figure out our priorities and the place of God in our lives. Desert spirituality addresses our most intimate thoughts and helps us analyze the roots of our spiritual setbacks. Its essence is to love the Lord with all our heart, soul, and mind (Matt 22:37). Starting in fourth-century Egypt, desert spirituality has become a global phenomenon. It has endured through the centuries because it is practical and simple; it tells us how to live out Scripture in our daily lives. It is also profound; it is deeply rooted in the theology of the incarnation and the renewal of creation by the resurrection. The desert fathers and mothers left us short wisdom sayings, revealing their inner experience in their long journey toward being with God. They speak about Scripture and prayer, but also about how to love our neighbors, discern our thoughts, and evaluate our daily activities. Come, learn from these desert dwellers as they teach us about the examination of thoughts, the discernment of the soul, and the balance of the heart.Then, just before Christmas this year she has another work coming out: The Coptic Christian Heritage: History, Faith and Culture (Routledge, 2013), 320pp.
The publisher provides the following details about this forthcoming book:
This book offers a comprehensive introduction to the heritage of Coptic Christians. The contributors combine academic expertise with intimate and practical knowledge of the Coptic Orthodox Church and Coptic heritage. The chapters explore historical, cultural, literary and material aspects, including:
- the history of Christianity in Egypt, from the pre-Christian era to the modern day
Students will find The Coptic Christian Heritage an invaluable introduction, whilst scholars will find its breadth provides a helpful context for specialised research.
- Coptic religious culture: theology, monasticism, spirituality, liturgy and music
- the Coptic language, linguistic expressions of the Coptic heritage and literary production in Greek, Coptic and Arabic .
- material culture and artistic expression of the Copts: from icons, mosaics and frescos to manuscript illuminations, woodwork and textiles.
Labels:
Coptology,
Copts,
Desert Fathers/Mothers
Thursday, July 26, 2012
Mothers of the Church
We live in a time of unprecedented interest in, and publications about, those early Christians whom we call the Fathers of the Church. But given the concerns of our age, the question is raised: were there any mothers, and if so, what do we know about them? A few books over the years have attempted to look at early Christian women, including Laura Swan's The Forgotten Desert Mothers: Sayings, Lives, and Stories of Early Christian Women; John Chryssavgis's In the Heart of the Desert: The Spirituality of the Desert Fathers and Mothers; and Eva Topping's Holy Mothers of Orthodoxy : Women and the Church. Now this year we have two new books treating these overlooked women:
Mike Aquilina and Christopher Bailey, Mothers of the Church: The Witness of Early Christian Women (Our Sunday Visitor Press, 2012), 160pp.
About this book the publisher tells us:
Meet the heroines of Christianity's formative years! Mike Aquilina and Christopher Bailey, in a follow-up to the best-selling The Fathers of the Church, have penned an inspiring companion volume on the Mothers of the Church that, like no other book, explores their impact on history and the Faith. Mothers of the Church: The Witness of Early Christian Women will reinforce Catholics understanding of the part played by women in the early Church. Drawing upon a wide spectrum of sources, it illustrates the many kinds of women that left their mark on sacred history by responding to God s call. Whether they were martyrs, abbesses, mothers, desert solitaries, or managers of large family businesses, these women s stories will encourage you and deepen your faith. Each chapter features a concise biography that is supplemented by quotes from the Fathers writings concerning the woman in question, poetry concerning her, and other ancient testimonials. The authors authoritative yet accessible writing style deftly explores the important impact of early Christian women. The Mothers of the Church include: Holy Women of the New Testament --St. Blandina --St. Perpetua and St. Felicity --St. Helena --St. Thecla --St. Agnes of Rome --St. Macrina --Proba the Widow --St. Marcella --St. Paula --St. Eustochium --St. Monica --Egeria the TouristThe second book, to be released next month, is Christine Valters Paintner, Desert Fathers and Mothers: Early Christian Wisdom Sayings, Annotated and Explained (Skylight, August 2012), 179pp.
About this book the publisher explains:
Wisdom from the very beginnings ofChristian monasticism can become a companion on your own spiritual journey. The desert fathers and mothers were ordinary Christians living in solitude in the deserts of Egypt, Palestine and Syria who chose to renounce the world in order to deliberately and individually follow God s call. They embraced lives of celibacy, labor, fasting, prayer, and poverty, believing that denouncing material goods and practicing stoic self-discipline would lead to unity with the Divine. Their spiritual practice formed the basis of Western monasticism and greatly influenced both Western and Eastern Christianity. Their writings, first recorded in the fourth century, consist of spiritual advice, parables and anecdotes emphasizing the primacy of love and the purity of heart as essential to spiritual life and authentic communion with God. Focusing on key themes of charity, fortitude, lust, patience, prayer, self-control and visions, the Sayings influenced the rule of St. Benedict and have inspired centuries of opera, poetry and art.
Labels:
Desert Fathers/Mothers,
Women
Monday, July 16, 2012
Jesus in the Desert
The Orthodox author Bradley Nassif together with Gary Burge have written a short new book Bringing Jesus to the Desert (Zondervan, 2012), 144pp.
About this book the publisher tells us:
Through the third to sixth centuries, great Christian men and women colonized the deserts of Palestine, Syria and Egypt, shaping the church through their examples of faith and devotion. History now knows them as the Desert Fathers and Mothers and their lives display an unswerving commitment to the love of Christ sorely needed in today's world. Bradley Nassif tells the story of how the deserts of the Holy Land forged a holy people and a lasting legacy of faith. As part of the Ancient Context, Ancient Faith series, Middle Eastern lands, culture and history directly undergird this exploration of ancient spirituality. Surveying the lives of Anthony of Egypt, Pachomius, Melania and others, Nassif demonstrates how the wilderness experiences chronicled in Scripture guided the practice of Christian faith in biblical lands. Bringing Jesus to the Desert can help pastors, Bible students and lay learners trace God's work in the past and draw on the power of God in the desert places of their own lives.
About this book the publisher tells us:
Through the third to sixth centuries, great Christian men and women colonized the deserts of Palestine, Syria and Egypt, shaping the church through their examples of faith and devotion. History now knows them as the Desert Fathers and Mothers and their lives display an unswerving commitment to the love of Christ sorely needed in today's world. Bradley Nassif tells the story of how the deserts of the Holy Land forged a holy people and a lasting legacy of faith. As part of the Ancient Context, Ancient Faith series, Middle Eastern lands, culture and history directly undergird this exploration of ancient spirituality. Surveying the lives of Anthony of Egypt, Pachomius, Melania and others, Nassif demonstrates how the wilderness experiences chronicled in Scripture guided the practice of Christian faith in biblical lands. Bringing Jesus to the Desert can help pastors, Bible students and lay learners trace God's work in the past and draw on the power of God in the desert places of their own lives.
Labels:
Bradley Nassif,
Christ,
Desert Fathers/Mothers,
Gary Burge
Friday, June 8, 2012
Listen to Your Elders
Interest in the Desert Fathers and Mothers remains high, as I have noted before, with many recent books testifying to this. Along comes another from John Wortley, Book of the Elders: Sayings of the Desert Fathers The Systematic Collection (Cistercian Press, 2012), 463pp.
About this book the publisher tells us:
In the early part of the fourth century, a few Christians, mostly men and some women, began to withdraw from the world to retreat into the desert, there to practice their new religion more seriously. The person who aspired to renounce the world first had to find an elder, a person who would accept him as a disciple and apprentice. To his elder (whom he would address as abba father) the neophyte owed complete obedience; from his abba he would receive provisions (as it were) for the road to virtue. In addition to the abba s own example of living, there was the verbal teaching of the elders in sayings and tales, setting out the theory and practice of the eremitic life. In due course, these sayings (or apophthegmata) were written down and, later, collected and codified. The earliest attempts to codify tales and sayings are now lost. As the collection grew, they were first organized alphabetically according to the name of the abba who spoke them, in a major collection known as the Apophthegmata Patrum Alphabetica. A supplementary collection, the Anonymous Apophegmata, followed. Later, both collections were combined and arranged systematically rather than alphabetically. This collection was created sometime between 500 and 575 and later went through a couple of major revisions, the second of which appeared sometime before 970. This second one was published in an excellent new critical edition, with a French translation, in 1993. Now, in Book of the Elders, John Wortley offers an English translation of this collection, based entirely on the Greek of that text.
Labels:
Desert Fathers/Mothers,
Patristics
Friday, December 30, 2011
Author Interview: Fr. Oliver Herbel
Earlier I drew attention to the recent publication of a new book by the American priest and historian Oliver Herbel. I interviewed him about his new book, and here are his thoughts:
AD: Tell us a bit about your background, including your other writing projects, blog, and work on American Orthodox history.
AD: Tell us a bit about your background, including your other writing projects, blog, and work on American Orthodox history.
My background is fairly “ecumenical.” I was baptized as a Lutheran and also later
confirmed as a Lutheran. At times, we
attended a Methodist parish and in high school I attended a Presbyterian
parish. In college, I met my future
wife, who was Lutheran, and we began attending church together. I graduated from Concordia College in
Moorhead, MN, went on to earn an MA in the history of Christianity from Luther
Seminary, an M.Div. from St. Vladimir’s Seminary, and a Ph.D. from Saint Louis
University (SLU). I was not church-shopping outside of the Lutheran church, but I learned about Orthodoxy from
professors at Concordia
College and became
Orthodox while yet a student at Luther Seminary.
At SLU, I initially was interested in the early church period but developed a strong interest in American Christianity. I have published articles on both early church and Byzantine topics as well as American topics. I currently have a couple of forthcoming book chapters on American Orthodoxy. I am writing an article on the Federated Orthodox Greek Catholic Primary Jurisdictions inAmerica ,
a 1942-1943 predecessor to SCOBA; and editing my dissertation with the intention
of publishing an edited version as a book.
I am also editing some research notes on iconography that I have had to
gather over the years for various speaking engagements and class lectures, with
the intention of publishing a book geared toward a more “popular”
audience. I also have some other future
projects in mind, but they will remain on the back burner for some time, I’m
afraid.
I am involved with the Orthodox History blog. That is the website for the Society for Orthodox Christian History in the Americas (SOCHA). Matthew Namee and others do much of the writing on that site, though. My main efforts with SOCHA involve the academic end such as the symposium we held this fall or the establishment of a peer-reviewed electronic journal. I did have a blog for a while that concentrated on historical theology, but it took too much time. I do keep up a parish blog, which this is much less involved.
At SLU, I initially was interested in the early church period but developed a strong interest in American Christianity. I have published articles on both early church and Byzantine topics as well as American topics. I currently have a couple of forthcoming book chapters on American Orthodoxy. I am writing an article on the Federated Orthodox Greek Catholic Primary Jurisdictions in
I am involved with the Orthodox History blog. That is the website for the Society for Orthodox Christian History in the Americas (SOCHA). Matthew Namee and others do much of the writing on that site, though. My main efforts with SOCHA involve the academic end such as the symposium we held this fall or the establishment of a peer-reviewed electronic journal. I did have a blog for a while that concentrated on historical theology, but it took too much time. I do keep up a parish blog, which this is much less involved.
AD: Your publisher's blurb notes that Serapion of Thmuis has
remained in "relative obscurity." How is it, then, that you first
found out about him and were drawn to write about him?
I first learned of St. Sarapion in a liturgical
theology class at St. Vladimir’s Seminary.
His euchologion, or collection of prayers, has been studied and I was
intrigued by them. For example, in the
Eucharist and at Baptism, rather than praying for the Holy Spirit’s descent,
the Word of God was asked to descend. I
looked into him a little more and learned that St. Antony the Great willed one
of his two cloaks to Sarapion. The other
he had willed to St. Athanasios the Great.
St. Athanasios’ letters to a “Sarapion” were, in fact, written to this
same Sarapion and this led me to research whether any of Sarapion’s own
writings were still extant. Some are:
two complete letters, a treatise against Manichaeans, and a letter partially
preserved, written to Antony ’s
disciples.
There are also a few quotes
(from sources no longer extant) found in the works of others. The partially preserved letter had been
translated into French, which I think most English readers can quickly learn to
read, but the two complete letters remained only in Greek and the treatise was
in Greek and German. By this point, I
was curious about this “mystery saint,” if you will, and the secondary
literature only piqued my interest.
There seemed to be some disagreement on whether his biblical
interpretation was “Alexandrian” (allegorical) or “Antiochene” (tending toward
typology and literalism). I was also
fascinated by his connection to the monks of the desert (one of his extant
letters is addressed to a group of such monks) and intrigued by his notion of
Hades/hell as a place of purgation, or education. Once I started translating him, I also
quickly realized just how indebted to Stoicism he had been. Of course, all early church fathers were so
indebted, but Sarapion especially so.
AD: For whom did you write the book--did you have a particular
audience in mind?
The book is, admittedly, primarily for an academic
audience. The first part of the book
consists of an introduction to Sarapion’s thought, focusing on his biblical
interpretation and use of Stoic philosophy.
I also argue for the authenticity of Sarapion’s authorship of the Letter to the Monks. Klaus Fitschen, the only the other
contemporary scholar to have devoted a book-length manuscript to Sarapion,
argued against Sarapion’s authorship of the letter, but for reasons I give in
the book, I think we would do well to follow the manuscript tradition in
accepting Sarapion’s authorship. The
second portion of the book consists of Sarapion’s own writings—the two letters
and the treatise. The treatise itself is
the sort of writing that will tend to interest scholars primarily as it’s an
extended theological argument and not a spiritual reflection of the kind that
would garner a large popular readership today.
All that said, my choir director read through the book I donated to our
parish and he found some portions of the treatise to be well worth the read. So, I really do think anyone who is theologically
informed would get something out of the book.
AD: As I have noted before, there seems to be a very great
interest in the Desert Fathers and Mothers today if the number of recent books
is anything to go by. Why do you think that is? What wisdom do figures like
Serapion and others in the desert have that people are looking for today?
I think there are many reasons people today are
interested in the Desert Fathers. I
think some people hearken back to them in a nostalgic/romantic sort of way—as
though they represent some lost time of real, vital spirituality and spiritual
warfare. Others, I believe, see the
Desert Fathers as representing a real spirituality not in a nostalgic sort of
way, but rather in a timeless way. Such
people see the Desert Fathers as being applicable even in today’s setting,
despite the radically divergent historical contexts.
Of course, there are also those who simply
find many of the stories wild and fantastic, and many stories are, but I think
most people fall into one of the first two categories, at least from what I can
tell. Personally, I think there is much
that is yet relevant. In St. Sarapion’s
case, I think his view of hell is one that will be thought-provoking,
especially in light of Rob Bell’s book Love Wins: A Book About Heaven, Hell, and the Fate of Every Person Who Ever Lived (which has caused a stir amongst Evangelicals) or even Christ the Conqueror of Hell: The Descent into Hades from an Orthodox Perspective by
Metropolitan Hilarion Alfeyev.
Additionally, Sarapion’s writings are important for studying early
Christian biblical interpretation—for noting how the “Scriptures” meant what we
call “the Old Testament” and how the Trinitarian Christian message was found to
be present within those Scriptures. I
also believe there is much practical wisdom, even though the writings I
translated are not “sayings” from St. Sarapion.
For example, his emphasis on free will and his reminder that Christians
are not dualists. I even find his Letter
to the Monks to be important as a reminder that the prayers of our
monastics have cosmological significance—the ongoing cycle of prayers help
sustain the universe.
AD: Are there things in Serapion's Pastoral Letters that you would
recommend to pastors to read today? Are there things you would not recommend?
I think both of
Sarapion’s letters are worthy pastoral reading.
The Letter to the Monks is a praise of the monastic life and a
reminder of the ascetic devotion to which monastics are called as well as a
reminder of the power of prayer. I also
think that many of things for which Sarapion praises the monks may be adopted
by all Christians. The Letter to
Bishop Eudoxios is a reminder that we should not let our bouts with
illnesses get us down but we should remember that we have our hope in God no
matter how dire our circumstances.
There is nothing I would not recommend that pastors read today, because I think pastors should be grounded in the fathers of the church and certainly shouldn’t be reading only what they happen to like in a particular father. This does not mean, however, that everything he wrote can have a direct application today. For example, at one point in his Letter to the Monks, Sarapion wrote an aside describing how complicated and bad and pathetic things can be for one who has chosen to raise a family in the world. Without a context permeated by Christianized Stoicism, this can be a difficult passage to accept and I do not find it readily applicable to the average parishioner inAmerica . A heightened view of a single, chaste,
monastic life has roots in St. Paul’s writings and continues on down throughout
church history but most Americans live in cities and towns with families in a
culture that presumes family life is the norm and is a good thing. Whether St. Sarapion would have written or
spoken otherwise for Christians living in Thmuis, the city in which he was the
bishop, we may never know, but I suspect he did. I think this example I’ve chosen to highlight
can serve as a reminder to keep in mind a writing’s context when assessing
applicability to contemporary life.
There is nothing I would not recommend that pastors read today, because I think pastors should be grounded in the fathers of the church and certainly shouldn’t be reading only what they happen to like in a particular father. This does not mean, however, that everything he wrote can have a direct application today. For example, at one point in his Letter to the Monks, Sarapion wrote an aside describing how complicated and bad and pathetic things can be for one who has chosen to raise a family in the world. Without a context permeated by Christianized Stoicism, this can be a difficult passage to accept and I do not find it readily applicable to the average parishioner in
AD: Were there any surprises as you were writing--unexpected
discoveries, developments you were not expecting?
His extended discussion
of the Book of Judith in his Against the Manichaeans caught me off
guard. I knew it was read by Christians,
of course, as it is scripture, but hadn’t run across a lengthy discussion of
that book in a theological treatise before.
I also found myself becoming sympathetic to Sarapion’s view of hell and how
he grounded that view in free will.
Prior to translating his treatise, I did not have any sympathy toward
that view, which I would now call “purgative inclusivism.” What changed my perception was a realization
that Sarapion’s position could not be reduced to mere “Origenism,” and, more
importantly, that his view was grounded in a dual belief in God’s unrelenting
mercy and humanity’s capacity for free will even after the fall. Finally, I was surprised at how Sarapion’s
biblical interpretation fit so well with some central themes found in Fr. John
Behr’s The Way to Nicaea. Sarapion
post-dates the second century, but there are some real parallels between how
St. Irenaeus responds to Valentinianism and how Sarapion responds to
Manichaeism.
AD: The Manicheans continue to provoke interest today among some,
especially those for whom "heresy" seems but an expression of a
"will to power" over ideological enemies. Remind us who the
Manicheans were in Serapion's context and why he opposed them.
The Manichaeans were a
real threat to the existence of the Church at that time. Mani was the third-century founder of the
religion and seems to have been raised as a member of some sort of Gnostic
sect. Mani’s dualistic tendencies
resonated with many and his belief that some are the elect and that such elect
lived a hyper-ascetic form of life enabled Manichaeans to infiltrate Christian
monasteries at the time. Manichaeism
taught that the cosmos was filled with trapped portions of light from the good
kingdom, which the evil kingdom had trapped in matter. Jesus was a savior figure for Manichaeism but
in the sense of being sent to inform people of this trapped light. I suppose one could argue for a Nietzschean
(“will to power”) interpretation of how Christianity came to view and defeat Manichaeism. Some pieces of history would fit such an
interpretation. Manichaeism becomes
outlawed within the Byzantine Empire because
it was viewed as a “Persian” religion, and indeed, a Persian religion directly
antagonistic toward Christianity.
Also,
one might view treatises such as Sarapion’s treatise or the slightly earlier
pastoral letter against Manichaeism by Patriarch Theonas of Alexandria as examples
of the church exerting a will to power over the Manichaeans. I think that interpretation does an injustice
to the actual difficulties on the ground, however. Such letters and treatises were written in
order to present real arguments in a lively and complicated theological
context. Furthermore, Sarapion’s
biblical interpretation proves to be so consistent with the general Christian
response to Gnosticism and Marcionism that I think it’s much more accurate to
read Sarapion’s treatise as continuing a tradition of biblical interpretation
rather than seeing it simply as an expression of exerting power. Related to this, incidentally, is the generally
accepted practice amongst scholars to call Gnostics and even Manichaeans
“Christians,” a phenomenon to which I do respond in my introduction. I honestly think the contemporary fascination
with Gnostic Christianity has to do with a desire by some to find some
romantic, nostalgic form of tolerant, enlightened Christianity. For others, I think the fascination exists
because defending Gnosticism can be a means of attacking the current
expressions of Christianity. If one
removes these two motivations, one greatly narrows the number of people
interested in Gnosticism.
AD: Conflicts over biblical interpretation are as old as
Christianity itself. Your book examines Serapion's biblical hermeneutics. Does
he offer us any hermeneutical guidance today?
I think Sarapion’s
biblical interpreation is a reminder that we Orthodox (and frankly, all
Christians) need to make sure we side-step the whole parameters of biblical
interpretation that were solidified in the late nineteenth century between
liberal scholarly uses of the various critical methods on the one hand or a
dogged insistence upon a particular literal reading on the other. Those parameters inevitably lead to things
like the Scopes Monkey Trial. We can,
should, and must do better than that. Indeed,
the same kind of Christocentric, Trinitarian reading of the Scriptures that St.
Sarapion performed may be found throughout Eastern Christian hymnography.
AD: Sum up briefly for us what the main contents and arguments of
the book.
The Introduction
discusses Sarapion’s historical context, his hermeneutics in the treatise (with
sub sections describing the Stoic elements, the Christocentric dimension, and
free will), and the two letters, with discussions of the concept of suffering,
the hermeneutics in the letters, and an argument for Sarapion’s authorship of
the Letter to the Monks. A
translation of those writings, a select bibliography, and an index conclude the
book.
Tuesday, October 18, 2011
Desert Fathers and Mothers
Interest in the Fathers, especially those of the deserts of Egypt, remains high. In the last decade more than a dozen books have appeared. Especially noteworthy are several volumes by John Chryssavgis, including In the Heart of the Desert: The Spirituality of the Desert Fathers and Mothers; and Tim Vivian, ed., Becoming Fire: Through the Year with the Desert Fathers and Mothers.
Now another book has been released just last week: David G.R. Keller, Desert Banquet: A Year of Wisdom from the Desert Mothers and Fathers (Liturgical Press, 2011), 256pp.
About this book, the publisher says:
Now another book has been released just last week: David G.R. Keller, Desert Banquet: A Year of Wisdom from the Desert Mothers and Fathers (Liturgical Press, 2011), 256pp.
About this book, the publisher says:
The wisdom of the desert fathers and mothers lies in their experiences of solitude, prayer, community life, work, and care for their neighbors. Their goal was transformation of their lives through openness to the presence and energy of God in Christ. They taught by example and by sharing narratives and sayings that reflect the deep human psychological and spiritual aspects of their journey toward authentic human life. The venue for their transformation was the whole person—body, mind, and spirit. They emphasized self-knowledge, humility, purity of heart, and love of God and neighbor. Far from being naïve, their sayings and narratives reflect honest struggles, temptations, and failures. They also demonstrate the disciplines of prayer and meditation that kept them centered in God as their only source of strength. The daily reflections in Desert Banquet introduce readers to a variety of these early Christian mentors and offer reflections on the significance of their wisdom for life in the twenty-first century.The noted Orthodox theologian John McGuckin, whose work we have discussed on here several times, has praised Keller's book thus:
"This delightful book presents a year´s daily readings from the Early Christian Desert tradition, with a very helpful spiritual commentary for each date. It is a veritable pocket Philokalia, such as we hear about in The Way of the Pilgrim. Fr. David Keller has done a great service in providing this very profound source of lectio divina for those seriously interested in the spiritual path."
Labels:
Desert Fathers/Mothers,
Patristics
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


